Home Page  What We Do  API Team  Procedures  Always Free  Equipment  Visual Stuff  Join Team API  Contact API
 
 
 

Return to Investigation Page

Appleton Paranormal Investigations 
 

Investigation Timeline of

Elsing’s Second Hand Shop
Stoughton, Wisconsin

April 19, 2008 
 

( Special Thanks to Tanya Rosenthal for her documentation ) 
 

Team Members Present:

John - Donna - Ann  - Keith

Tanya - Dawn - Jeff 
 

      On Saturday, April 19, 2008, Appleton Paranormal Investigations was invited to investigate Elsing’s Second Hand Shop in Stoughton, Wisconsin.  What follows is the final report of our investigation and any evidentiary findings from that evening. 
 

      Prior to beginning our investigation, the team set up stationary video cameras in both the Furniture Room & the Holiday Room.  Also, a motion detector was positioned in what is referred to as the “Pizza Room” in the far back area of the lower level. 
 

      API broke into two teams of 4 investigators.  Team A consisted of John, Donna, Keith and Tanya.  Team B consisted of Ann, Dawn & Jeff, and was accompanied by store owner Vicky Elsing. 
 

      At 8:36 pm, the investigation began.  Team A went upstairs to the attic.  Team B went downstairs to the lower level.  Both teams investigated for approximately 40 minutes before regrouping on the main level.

      During this time, Team A experienced a cold spot and varied EMF readings in the upstairs area.  Team B experienced a slight feeling of dizziness by a couple of their members in the Furniture Room.  No evidence gathered during this time revealed anything anomalous. 
 

      At 9:34 pm, both teams began stage 2 of their investigations.  Team A proceeded downstairs, while Team B moved upstairs.

      During this time, Team A encountered strange EMF readings in the Holiday Room.  At a location approximately 3 feet directly inside the doorway and straight ahead.

The reading, oddly, moved from the room average of approximately 1.0, all the way up to 2.6 about 10 inches off the ground.  Moving the EMF detector up or down from that point would cause the reading to lower.  This is strange, as any under-floor electrical conduits would most likely cause the spike to continue all the way to floor level.  Also – moving the detector off the axis aligned with the doorway, would also cause a loss in EMF reading numbers.

      At 9:45 pm, Team A, working with the EMF detector, asked for any spirits present to manipulate the EMF numbers.  The EMF detector was kept still for this portion, either in hand or on the floor.  This is the result: 
 

    EMF #’s climbing .9, 1.0, 1.1 
     

    John asks spirit: “Can you make it a 10?” (aka: 1.0) “How high can you make it?”  
     

    EMF detector goes from: 1.6…. 1.8… 2.1, 2.2, 2.3 (aka: 23) 
     

    Keith asks: “Can you make it go back down?”  
     

    EMF detector goes from 1.7 (17), 1.5 (15), 1.6 (16). 
     

    John asks: “Can you make it go over 20 (2.0) or back down to zero?

      If you can do this, Donna will read a book to you”.  
 

      EMF detector goes to 1.0. 
 

      John asks: “Can you make it go lower?” 
 

      EMF detector goes to .7.  
 

      John asks: “Lower yet?  Can you make a noise?” (no response on EVP),

    “Can you move something?” (no response) “Do you want to go in the other room and read a book?” (no response) 
     

During this possible ‘communication’ using the EMF Detector, the detector was not manipulated in any way.  The numbers appeared to move as requested but no fluctuating source of electricity was known to be in the area to manipulate the readings in any way. 
 

      Afterwards, Team A moved into the Furniture Room and conducted an EVP session, then investigated the rest of the basement area. 
 

      At 10:01pm, Team B entered the main floor from the attic. 
 

      During this time, a Team A member felt a cold feeling during the EVP session in the furniture room.  Also, while investigating the area of the door to the furnace room, unexplained EMF readings were detected outside the doorway, near and about 8-10 inches away from the hinges of the door.  The reading moved from an ambient area reading of .6 – 1.0 all the way up into the 2.5 – 3.0 range in one particular area.  However, readings taken by the furnace did not match those outside the door.  A conduit on the ceiling did cause a spike in the readings, but the area in question was 3-4 feet from that source and fluctuated.  This is unexplained. 
 
 

Prior to the next round of investigation, the stationary video camera in the furniture room was moved to the Attic.  Team A was going to leave this camera in the attic to record any incidents in that area – as no team members were going to be investigating in the area.  When the camera recording began, the camera battery was fully charged and showed 119 minutes of battery time.   
 

      At 11:42pm, Team A began its investigation on the 1st floor.  Team B heading to basement.  During this investigation period, at 12:01 am in the toy room during an EVP & dousing rod session, team A member Keith’s camera shut off without explanation. Besides a couple of unexplained noises such as a ‘pop’ or creak were heard, but overall, no other incidents occurred during Team A’s 1st floor investigation.  John & Keith also performed an EVP session in the far back storage area of the 1st floor, an area that owner Vicky stated had never been investigated.  Review of the recording afterwards showed no responses detected. 
 

      During this time, Team B was investigating the basement.  At one point, while they were in the back room behind the furnace area, Vicky asked the question, “Do you like it when I have the investigators come in and try to talk to you?"

      Investigator Dawn heard a clear and distinct whispered “No” from her right side.  No other team members heard it, and it was not caught on audio tape, therefore it can not be verified and is classified as a ‘personal experience’. 
 

At approximately 12:25, Team A moved to the Attic area to investigate while Team B continued working in the basement.  Upon arriving in the attic, John noticed that the video camera that had been set up was not on.  When the camera was checked, the battery had been drained.  The time on the tape showed that the camera, which had showed a battery life of 119 minutes at the onset, had only lasted approximately 24 minutes.  A review of the video tape showed no visual anomalies, however there were several unexplained noises caught on the video tape, including one very clear single ‘knock’ which sounded as if it came from the immediate area of the camera.  There were no investigators in the attic at the time, and there is no known cause for that sound to occur.

Various road noises and other sounds which sounded like voices were detected as well during this recording, but were dismissed as possible voices from outside the building. 
 

      Team A conducted a mini EVP session while upstairs, and during part of that session, John asked about the story of the Chief of Police falling out of the back window of the building.  When John asked, “Is this true?”, a faint response was later heard on the recording, possibly saying “No”.  This was the only EVP responses heard during this session. 
 

      At 1:18 am, both groups teamed up to perform a lantern-lit EVP / Dousing Rod session in the Furniture Room.

Present were: Vicki, Ann, Tanya, Keith, Dawn, Jeff, Donna, John.  ( Keith had left for the evening to return home ). 
 

      1:19 am- Vicki heard a childs voice, Dawn heard a whisper.  No one else heard anything.  The following portion of this report contains the details of this session: 
 

      1: 20am- John EVP: “Is there anyone here with us?” (no response), “would anyone like to speak with us?” (no response), “Move something?” (no response), “Show us you are here?” (no response), “Knock?” (no response), “Tired of having us here?” (no response), “Would you like us to leave?” (no response).

Vicki asks John: “How do you know if they want you to leave?” John responds: “They could knock 2 x’s, or move the ball”. 
 

      1:27am Dousing rod session begins.  (Ann is holding the rods, John asks the questions) 
 

John says: “Can you uncross the rods to show us that you are here?” “Make the rods come straight out”. (Rods go straight) 
 

“To confirm, can you cross the rods so we know it is you?” (rods crossed) 
 

“Are you a man?” “If so, uncross the rods” (no response) 
 

“Girl / Female?” “uncross the rods” (rods uncrossed) 
 

“Thank You!” “Do you live here?” “cross the rods” (Rods crossed) 
 

“Are you an adult?” “Uncross the rods” (no response) 
 

“Are you a young girl, or a child?” “Uncross the rods” (rods uncrossed) 
 

“Can you straighten the rods please?” ( rods straighten ) “Perfect! Thank You!” John asks the investigation team if everyone can see this.  Everyone is watching intently. 
 

“Do you like having us here?” “cross the rods” (no movement) 
 

“Does it bother you that we are here?” “cross the rods” (rods crossed) 
 

(Vicki asks John: “Does that make you feel bad?”  John replies: “I don’t know yet”.) 
 

“Does it bother you because so many groups have come through here?” “Uncross the rods” (rods uncrossed) 
 

“Do you get bored w/ the same questions all the time?” “Cross rods” (rods crossed) 
 

“Does it make you tired?” “uncross the rods” (rods uncrossed) 
 

“Are you here by yourself?” “uncross the rods” (no response) 
 

“Are there others (spirits)?” “Uncross the rods” (rods uncrossed) 
 

“I am going to count with numbers, when I get to the number of spirits, cross the rods?” 
 

“one,… two… three…four…” (rods crossed) 
 

“There are four others plus yourself making 5 total, if that is correct uncross the rods” (rods uncrossed) 
 

“Keep rods straight please, Thank You!” 
 

“Are there other girls with you?” “cross the rods” (rods crossed) 
 

“Boys / Men?” “uncross the rods” (rods uncrossed) 
 

“Is there a man named Carl?” “cross the rods” (Rods started to cross, but didn’t finish)

( This is in reference to former owner Carl Bratvold, who according to newspaper reports apparently passed away in the building ) 
 

“Are you older than 5 years old?” “cross the rods” (rods crossed) 
 

“Younger than 10 years old?” “uncross the rods” (rods uncrossed) 
 

“I’m going to count again, when I get to your age… cross the rods” 
 

“6… 7… 8… 9…(rods crossed) 
 

“you are pretty smart for a nine year old!” 
 

“Why are you here?” “Did you have an accident while you were here?” “uncross rods” (no response) 
 

“Were you sick?” “uncross the rods” (no response) 
 

“Did your mom / dad live here w/ you?” “uncross the rods” ( rods uncrossed) 
 

John to Vicki: “Vicki, did you have a name for this young spirit?” Vicki said: “I used to call her Emily,… I wanted to call her Emma,… I have stopped calling her a name”. 
 

“Can you point the rods straight out?” ( Ann adjust the rods herself ) “Thank You Ann “ (Giggle) 
 

“Is there a name we can call you?” (no response) 
 

“Vicki sometimes calls you Emily, or Emma- Is either one of them your name?” “If so, cross the rods” (no response) 
 

“Do you have any brothers / sisters?” “if so, cross the rods” (no response) 
 

“Did you go to school here?” “Cross rods” (rods crossed) 
 

John says to the group: I get the feeling that she doesn’t know that “it” (death) happened.  Vicki responds:  You are the second one to say that. 
 

John asks if the rods are straight??  Ann responds: “A couple of times they have pointed toward Vicki, is because I mentally said to the spirits show me where you are.  The rods went to Vicki, then to Johns left side. 
 

“Are you getting tired of answering questions?” “cross the rods” (rods crossed before he had completely finished asking the question!) 
 

“I don’t want to upset you, or tire you out… If it is OK to ask 2 more questions- uncross the rods” (rods uncrossed) 
 

Donna said to the group: “Maybe she would let us talk to someone else?” 
 

“Is there someone else here that would want to talk?” “Cross the rods” (no response) 
 

“Just give me one more question… I’m drawing a blank…(pause) Any ideas? (said to the group)? 
 

Tanya said to John: “Ask her if she is dead?”  
 

“Last question to you…Are you Alive? If so, can you cross the rods?” (rods crossed) 
 

“If there is anything else you want to say… We will leave our machines here for you to talk into.” 
 

Last 3 minutes of session was dead air.  End session.  
 
 
 
Return to Investigation Page